2.4.12

Should the legal drinking limit be lowered? When teenagers can hold a hot gun but not a cold beer.

Saint Patrick’s Day is a holiday celebrated March 17th characterized by wearing green attire, various public parades, the end of Lent and most importantly, massive binge drinking.

Although the drinking age in U.S. is higher than those in European countries, the United States has an increasing death rate from alcohol abuse. In the United Kingdom alcohol causes around 9,000 deaths per year, but in the United States over 75,000 deaths per year are attributed to alcohol abuse. Underage drinking has always been an issue regardless of the purchase of alcohol by anyone under the age of 21 being restricted by law in countries like ours.

The age limit in Michigan was raised to 21 in hopes of keeping alcohol out of high schools. According to County Wide Newspaper, Kalamazoo County ranked 7th in the state for underage drinking.  The state is attempting to fix this problem by creating more laws against underage drinking, but is it really working? It seems as though no matter how many new laws are formed, kids are going to continue to drink even though they know it is wrong.  When asked, many students tend to answer with sarcastic comments such as “Wait, I can go to war and die for my country but I can’t drink?” or young couples joke, “Let’s get married, but not be able to toast at our wedding”. At 18 we are considered age of majority, or adults, able to vote and go to war but we are forbidden to drink.



One must also ask the question, “How are underage kids able to obtain alcohol?” Networking has provided students connections with legal drinkers who supply them with alcohol. Some even go as far as asking them for their old I.D., to some extent considered stealing someone else’s identity, which is a bigger felony than underage drinking.  If students will go out of their way to buy alcohol, why not lower the drinking age to stop them from soliciting it to wrong or even dangerous people?  Since recent laws are found to cause more harm than good, then maybe it would be wise to take action and consider lowering the age limit or engage in more effective measures.

The state of Ohio recently instituted a law that allows individuals between the ages of 18 and 21 to consume alcohol in the presence of a legal guardian. As a result, Ohio has seen a dramatic decrease in alcohol related fatalities. If the national drinking age were lowered minors would become more familiar with the effects and dangers of alcohol consumption at a younger age. Also, bars provide a safe, public, supervised place to enjoy the intoxicating effects of alcohol. If minors were allowed to drink at bars bartenders would be able to monitor the amount of alcohol they consume, and the public setting would reduce the chance that an inebriated individual might be assaulted.

"If the age were lowered, at least
I would have been at home
and safe..."
 In an interview, student Alyshia Norris admitted to having drunk before her 21st birthday.  She says she did it because it felt exciting to be breaking that rule.  “I was kind of a goodie goodie in high school.  I didn’t really do anything to try to break the rules.  Drinking early just felt exciting, and I did it to a good deal of excess for about a year around my birthday.  If the age were lowered, at least I would have been at home and safe instead of on my own and possibly putting myself in dangerous situations.” 

Does the current drinking age help or hinder the original goal of keeping alcohol out of underage hands? Students “pre-game” before leaving their house so they go out to parties already intoxicated and are exempted from drinking through the rest of the day. The worry of getting caught is pressuring them to drink in their homes and surpassing their physical alcoholic tolerance. By introducing individuals to the opportunity to consume alcohol at a younger, and more supervised age European countries have experienced fewer deaths related to alcohol consumption.  
Students pre-gaming in St. Patrick's Day,
also an example of reckless behavior.



Over 42 percent of American high school students have consumed alcohol, and that number is even higher for underage college students. Many choose to consume alcohol despite its illegality and consequences. By keeping the national drinking age at 21 years of age minors feel forced to consume alcohol secretively in unsupervised settings. This scenario can lead to alcohol poisoning or even rape because of a lack of supervision.

"...we are old enough to
make our own decisions,
and even drink responsibly."
Stephen Bus, a 19-year-old freshman at Western Michigan University, vehemently agrees that the age limit should be lowered. Many young students share his view, arguing that at 18, teenagers should be given the liberty to drink as they are much more mature at that age.  “I don’t see why one must be 18 and over for a lot of other things in this country, apart from the consumption of alcohol. I feel that at this age we are old enough to make our own decisions, and even drink responsibly.”

 MLive posted on its website and article titled “Roundup of St. Patrick's Day festivities across Michigan” http://www.mlive.com/st-patricks-day/index.ssf/2012/03/roundup_of_st_patricks_day_festivities_across_michigan.html, which provides us with photo galleries of the events that occurred during St. Patty’s. These activities were for people of all ages, but what we don’t see is the “younger” side of the holiday and what actually happens behind closed doors, or in this particular case, outdoors. The following video is a compilation of scenes that were shot at Campus Court’s pool party:





Edited by John Barrios and Sugel Gamal
 
Underage drinking is an unavoidable occurrence. The majority of the students who attended this event lived in the premises and were able to drink legally. Witnesses confirm that minors outside were arrested at the scene for trying to get into the party. Numerous students under the influence had had so much to drink they couldn’t behave politely in public, therefore authorities were forced to seize the party early. After viewing this video we can see that people who are legally able to drink do not go over their heads and have even more fun under conscientious drinking. Wouldn’t you consider it best to lower the drinking age and decrease the pressure placed upon those who are forbidden from and tempted to binge drink?


References

No hay comentarios:

Publicar un comentario